Value Insights Value Insights Value Insights Value Insights
  • Home
  • Trainings
    • For Individuals
      • ITIL 4 Foundation eLearning
    • For Companies
      • Our Success Model
      • ITIL
        • ITIL 4 Foundation
      • SAFe
        • Leading SAFe
        • SAFe for Teams
        • SAFe Scrum Master
        • SAFe Product Owner / Product Manager
      • Scrum
        • Registered Scrum Master (RSM)
        • Registered Product Owner (RPO)
        • Registered Scrum Master & Product Owner (RSMPO)
    • Learnify E-Learning
    • Pricing
  • Services
  • About Us
  • Blog
    • ITIL 4 Big Picture
  • Contact
  • Shop
    • Offers
    • Cart
    • My Account
  • EnglishEnglish
    • EnglishEnglish
Value Insights Value Insights
  • Home
  • Trainings
    • For Individuals
      • ITIL 4 Foundation eLearning
    • For Companies
      • Our Success Model
      • ITIL
        • ITIL 4 Foundation
      • SAFe
        • Leading SAFe
        • SAFe for Teams
        • SAFe Scrum Master
        • SAFe Product Owner / Product Manager
      • Scrum
        • Registered Scrum Master (RSM)
        • Registered Product Owner (RPO)
        • Registered Scrum Master & Product Owner (RSMPO)
    • Learnify E-Learning
    • Pricing
  • Services
  • About Us
  • Blog
    • ITIL 4 Big Picture
  • Contact
  • Shop
    • Offers
    • Cart
    • My Account
  • EnglishEnglish
    • EnglishEnglish
Aug 30

When you are on a project, are you doing railroad or combat planning?

  • 30.08.2022
  • ValueInsights
  • No Comments
  • Agile

What are the differences you may ask and why does it matter? Discover in this post those two very different ways of planning and how they impact your projects!

Combat vs Railroad planning - Freepik, fxquadro and frimufilms

Table of Contents

Railroad vs combat planning

Railroad planning looks meticulous and complex while combat appears messy and frightening. Based on this choice of words, it seems that railroad planning should be use for planning projects. Right?

Well, let’s look at Dantar P. Oosterwal definition of those two very different types of plannings. We will start by the railroad before going to the combat one.

Railroad planning

“Railroad planning is effective for tasks that are predictable and consistent but does not accommodate change well”…”In railroad planning, minor schedule disruptions can have major implications on the project as a whole, because tasks and activities are so tightly interrelated”

Railroad planning is akin to linear or predictive approaches in project management. Scope of project is well defined, schedule and resources boundaries are defined upfront. When scope changes happen, the goal is to limit them to the strict minimum (e.g. by a change control board) so that they affect as little as possible the schedule, resources or quality. 

The success criteria of those projects is often to be on scope, on time and on budget.

This usually works well for work such as construction building where business requirements and the way to address them technically is known. Related activities and tasks’ duration as well. Those great predictability elements help to drive the project to completion.

But as soon as business requirements are moving into fuzzy areas and are evolving throughout the project, being on time and on schedule based on an original scope of your project will not matter…

So what is the alternative?

The alternative is combat planning!

Combat planning

Where “plans are good until the first bullet flies”. As per Oosterwal’s definition:

“Combat planning is suited to turbulent and ever-changing conditions…Combat planning favors the prepared and is based on planning and committing to key objectives as a group. Everyone must develop alternatives in order to ensure achieving shared goals”

Combat planning is looking to reach shared outcomes without following to the letter a carefully written plan. Goals are set up with the team(s) and a general direction on how to get there is devised.

When faced with uncertainties and changes, the team(s) review and adapt their approaches, keeping the end goal in mind. Achieving the objectives is far more important than the way to get there. Circumstances may drive changes in the goals to achieve or in worst cases, their cancellations.

Doing combat planning is to ever adapt your approach based on the actual conditions, not the planned ones.

Conclusion: trains or fights?

Combat planning is well suited for projects containing high to medium degree of uncertainties in business and technical requirements. Combat planning is fit to the VUCA world. 

Example of combat planning can be found in Agile frameworks such as Scrum. For more on this, you can check “When NOT to use Scrum“ which details the conditions upon which Scrum thrives.

Railroad planning is well suited for projects with low degree of uncertainties in business and technical requirements. It works well for projects whose tasks and related duration to execute a well defined scope are known.

I hope that above helped you to make the differences between the two approaches.

And you, what is your approach to project planning? What has worked for you and your teams? Let us know in the comments!

Best Regards,

Your Value Insights

Note: This post was inspired by the book “The Lean Machine” from Dantar P. Oosterwal which talks about his experience of applying lean principles to product development at Harley Davidson. Quotes in italic are from the book.

Contact Us!
Please provide your title
Please provide your title
Please provide your first name
Please provide your first name
Please provide your first name
Please provide your first name
Please provide your Email address
Please provide your Email address
Do you want us to call you?
Field is required!
Field is required!
Please provide your phone number
Please provide your phone number
Please provide a subject
Please provide a subject
Please type your message
Please type your message
I accept the General Terms and Conditions
Field is required!
Field is required!
Submit

Check out our latest blog posts


 

The Lean StartUp Eric Ries

The Lean Start Up: conduct scientific experiments while doing Agile

03.02.2023
Read More
official itil 4 foundation candidate syllabus axelos peoplecert value insights training

The official ITIL 4 Foundation Candidate Syllabus explanied

26.11.2022
Read More
Scaling Agile Frameworks terminology

Scaling Agile Frameworks Terminology Comparison

05.09.2022
Read More
Everyone talks about Scrum

So what is that Scrum that everyone talks about?

17.08.2022
Read More
5 Agile things without being Agile

5 Agile elements that you can use WITHOUT being Agile

27.06.2022
Read More
Japanese terms in Lean-Agile

Japanese terms in Lean-Agile

12.05.2022
Read More
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Reddit
  • Pinterest
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • E-Mail

About The Author

Struggling to deliver faster, stronger better? We support your Lean-Agile transformation through professional trainings and coaching. Our mission is to make better workplaces! Places where people work aligned to a common vision and goals in a sustainable and engaging manner. Places where people work for a greater good with a sense of purpose, value and mastery.

Leave a reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending

  • itil 4 foundation badge mock exam quiz questions answers value insights switzerland basel Are you ready to pass the ITIL 4 Foundation exam? Try our Quiz! 117.3k views | 103 comments
  • itil 4 practices overview big picture all practice axelos service management itsm value insights service value chain system The ITIL 4 Practices Overview 36.7k views | 1 comment
  • scrum product owner badge png professional certified scruminc PO agile switzerland Scrum Product Owner exam practice test questions: PSPO I, CSPO, RPO 20k views | 0 comments
  • How to get the ITIL 4 foundation digital badge How to get the ITIL 4 Foundation Digital Badge 19.9k views | 9 comments
  • prince2 foundation 2017 mock exam practice test free questions answers quiz preparation axelos peoplecert value insights switzerland agile training Ready for PRINCE2 Foundation? Check this 40 FREE sample practice exam questions! 17.2k views | 2 comments

Our Mock Exams

  • itil 4 foundation official mock exam practice questions peoplecert ITIL 4 Foundation Official Mock Exam
    Rated 0 out of 5
    CHF 60,00
  • itil 4 foundation elearning online training course official exam accredited ato organization axelos peoplecert ITIL® 4 Foundation eLearning - Basic
    Rated 5.00 out of 5
    CHF 665,00 CHF 465,00
  • How to become a Scrum Master How to become a Scrum Master eLearning
    Rated 0 out of 5
    CHF 89,00 CHF 39,00
  • itil 4 foundation elearning online training course official exam accredited ato organization axelos peoplecert ITIL® 4 Foundation eLearning - Premium
    Rated 5.00 out of 5
    CHF 725,00 CHF 525,00
  • 160 Professional Scrum Master I mock exam questions prepared by Value Insights, simulating the official scrum.org PSM I exam. Professional Scrum Master I (PSM I) Mock Exams - 160 Practice Questions
    Rated 0 out of 5
    CHF 12,99
  • 80 Professional Scrum Master I mock exam questions prepared by Value Insights, simulating the official scrum.org PSM I exam. Professional Scrum Master I (PSM I) Mock Exam - 80 Practice Questions
    Rated 0 out of 5
    CHF 8,99

Follow us on Social Media

  • facebook
  • linkedin
  • youtube

Privacy Policy

General Terms and Conditions (GTC)

ITIL® is a registered trademark of AXELOS Limited, used under permission of AXELOS Limited. All rights reserved.

value insights swiss security trust ssl certificate

“Agile by Vision – Trainers by Passion”

value insights gmbh logo transparent grey

Looking for something?

Change Currency

(CHF) CHF (Default)
  • (€) EUR
  • ($) USD
  • (£) GBP

Popular Products

  • itil 4 foundation elearning online training course official exam accredited ato organization axelos peoplecert ITIL® 4 Foundation eLearning - Premium
    Rated 5.00 out of 5
    CHF 725,00 CHF 525,00
  • itil 4 foundation elearning online training course official exam accredited ato organization axelos peoplecert ITIL® 4 Foundation eLearning - Basic
    Rated 5.00 out of 5
    CHF 665,00 CHF 465,00
  • itil 4 foundation official mock exam practice questions peoplecert ITIL 4 Foundation Official Mock Exam
    Rated 0 out of 5
    CHF 60,00
  • How to become a Scrum Master How to become a Scrum Master eLearning
    Rated 0 out of 5
    CHF 89,00 CHF 39,00
© 2022 Website built and maintained by Value Insights
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie settingsACCEPT Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are as essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
SAVE & ACCEPT